How Common Is Vasectomy Failure?

As a method of contraception, vasectomy is on a par with the Pill, with its less than 1 in 100 chance of failure. Unfortunately, if a couple are not properly informed, they may miss important information about how best to manage their contraception around the time of the procedure.

Reasons for vasectomy failure

1. Vasectomy doesn’t take effect immediately as there may be sperm in the reproductive tract for several weeks after the surgery. It’s vital that other forms of birth control are used during this time. A semen sample taken around 6 to 8 weeks afterwards can detect the presence or absence of sperm, moving or not moving, dead or alive.

2. In some cases, vasectomy failure is due to a technical error, but in most cases it is due to recanalization, which refers to the spontaneous reconnection of the cut ends of the vas. Recanalization can be due to sperm granuloma which are tiny balls of debris that form from a combination of sperm, scar tissue and white blood cells where the incision was made. The cells that line the inside of the vas deferens grow through the scar tissue and create a new channel through which the sperm are now able to move. Some surgeons leave a gap between the two cut ends in order to reduce the risk of recanalization.

The rate of vasectomy failure is very low, estimated at between 0.5% and 1%. The success or failure depends on the doctors’ skill and experience the method used to block the tubes. This is why testing semen samples is essential.

You can actually interview potential doctors about their success and complication rates before deciding on who should perform the vasectomy for you. In rare cases, if persistent live sperm are shown to be present in semen checks following your vasectomy, the procedure will have to be repeated.

Once you have had your vasectomy, you should organize a follow-up examination for 12 months after your procedure to ensure that there are no new or residual sperm. Doctors highly recommend this follow-up check, yet one study revealed that only 3% actually took their advice.

  • ACA

    My wife became pregnant 14 years after I had a vasectomy . She insisted she did not have an affair.
    I was stunned to say the least and a year later plucked up the courage to have a further test. The Doctor’s response was and I quote” It is medically impossible for you to make anyone pregnant – you are sterile – not even any dead ones in the test ”
    The child was lost at 3 months of the pregnancy – despite all the evidence my wife insists she did not stray .
    I stayed as my children were entering Uni and year 10 High School and I did not want to upset their education .
    But I can tell you it has not been a happy home and interestingly I am now continually being accused of being with other women when I speak to one now some 20 years later..
    In some ways I wish I had left but in others I am glad I stayed as both my children gained an excellent Uni education .
    For me I am a lost soul

  • Deathstopshere

    As I was studying I was looking for more information on the failure rates of a vasectomy. Then I read your post ACA. I feel for the troubles you have gone through and I hope you find enough solace in the fact that your children have an education.
    If you are still struggling with the idea that the child might not be yours, you could contemplate a DNA test. Either way, hope you read this and you have a fine day.

  • tee pee

    Why didn’t you be there for your wife? Of course she didn’t stray. It happens. And now you have made this all about you. She lost a baby!!

Please feel free to email us at if you have any questions or comments!
© Earth's Magic Inc 2000 - 2017. All Rights Reserved. [ Disclaimer | Privacy Statement ]